1. #1
    Unregistered Guest

    Job reservation are Violation of right to equality or Not.

    debate on job reservations are violation of right to equality or not
    please send this answer on my email id sunflwr31@gmail.com

  2. #2
    Raju22711 is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Location
    Rajasthan
    Posts
    1,610

    Re: Job reservation are Violation of right to equality or Not.

    Quote Originally Posted by Unregistered View Post
    debate on job reservations are violation of right to equality or not
    please send this answer on my email id sunflwr31@gmail.com


    Dear Aspirant,

    -->> Jobs reservation is violation of Right of equality.

    -->> This rigt of equality is one of the best right provided by constitution to Indians.

    -->> Well the constitutation makers also thaught that there should be some special right to the backward classes.

    -->> So the reservation in job had been started by government.

    -->> To bring them forward is neccessary.

    -->> Through reservation the backward pepole also get chances in government jobs and feel them equal to other people.

    -->> So it was mandatory to give reservation that time.

    -->> But now politics has came in the system. Everyone want to make vote bank strong, so they are making misuse of reservation system and giving reservation to those who do not need it.

  3. #3
    amtul is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2012
    Location
    hyderabad india
    Posts
    309

    Re: Job reservation are Violation of right to equality or Not.

    RIGHT TO EQUALITY :ARTICLE 14 _18 of Indian constitution deals with right to equality...
    my answer will be a bigggggg no...As every citizen is basically holds certain rights and equality.Right to hold the government job and right to reservation..
    candiadate have the right to hold reservation and job..to hold job by reservation is not a violation of right to equality...
    thank you..

  4. #4
    shivangi mudgil is offline Junior Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2012
    Posts
    27

    Re: Job reservation are Violation of right to equality or Not.

    Reseravations means providing more facilities to the persons who don't have the facilities.
    But why the govt is giving reservations. To know about the reason we need to know about our Indian culture.
    In olden days due to some bad rules in Indian culture we devide our selfs as High cast people and Low cast people.The high cast people always keep away the low cast people.If low cast people touch them they felt badly.The low cast people were always under the high cast people due to this the low cast people couldn't develop themselfs. Even though the low cast people got jobs by doing hard work the high cast people neglected them. that's why a lot of gap established between low cast people and high cast people.

    And also our Indian culture devide men and women seperately. They said women is only for doing work at home and for marraige purpose only. Then automatically man got high power than woman.

    This process was continuing so many years. After that we independance day. Then the creator of our federal Dr. BR Ambedkar realised the problem.
    Then our govt provided reservations to the low cast people to cover the gap between low cast people and high cast people and also privided 33% reservations to the women.

    But these reservations has been utilising not only poor persons bu also rich persons. Because before ibdependent India some low cast people developed very well by oing hard work.

    In OCs also there are so many persons who are very poor.But the govt doesn't providing reservations to them even though they are poor.

    Now the govt is giving reservations to OBC depends on his father's income.But if his father is earning money on business or from private sector the govt not considering it as his income.DUE TO THIS THE RICHER IS BECOMING MORE RICHER AND THE POORER BECOMING MORE POORER.

    Now woman is developing equally with man. she is developed very well by using resrvatons. now is it necessary to them? and even though govt is providing 33% resrvations to them the literacy for women is less.Because in villages our culture was deeply rooted in their minds and the educated girls, rich girls are using reservations highly. But it is not necessary to them. If the govt provides more funds to village girls by decreasing reservations on rich girls then village girls will be develop.

    Due to the reservations so many persons are changing their cast.

    finally what i am saying is " if the govt provides reservations based on income of his/her father by considering the income in any manner then only all will utilise reservations properly"

  5. #5
    Ravi dikshith is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    Apr 2012
    Location
    Nidadavole,Andhrapradesh
    Posts
    2,966

    Re: Job reservation are Violation of right to equality or Not.

    Hello dude!

    Right to equality is one of the 6 rights that have been granted to us.It is described as "The state shall not discriminate aganist any citizen on grounds only of religion,race,caste,sex,place or birth or any of them.

    There shall be equality of opportunity for all citizens in matters relating to employment or appointment to any office under the state.No citizen shall,on grounds only of religion,race,caste,sex,descent,place of birth,residence or any of them,be ineligible for, or discriminated aganist in respect of,any employment or office under the state.

    So according to the above mentioned lines,then there should not be any reservation in the jobs but the government is not following it.

    Even though they are providing reservation in Education as well as payment of fees but it is not necessary to provide reservation in jobs.So let's hope that the government changes the rule.

    HOPE THE INFORMATION HELPED YOU AND ALL THE BEST.

  6. #6
    sauravmillion is offline Junior Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Location
    Bhubaneswar,Odisha
    Posts
    556

    Re: Job reservation are Violation of right to equality or Not.

    Hello Dear

    Reservations to certain class was made to make sure that each and every individual from the backward class would get benefits out of it.But if you look at the current scenario. Its really pity to see that a poor Brahmin candidate has to be genius to survive or else have to stay poor forever.
    reservation_stir.jpg
    Now a days a backward class candidate works in a good organization with a better pay role and has got all the lucrative things maintained in their homes.But a general category candidate has to struggle and compromise with the job positions in various govt and P.S.U sectors despite of the fact that he/she is showing performance in work and is also having a good percentage in 10th,12th and graduation.

    I think govt cannot remove this reservation because it covers the major vote bank of our country. See I am not against this reservation but govt should also decide to whom this reservation should be given.They should set certain eligibility criteria for this reservations For example family income above 5lakh wont be allowed to get relaxation.

    I agree that govt examination have relaxations towards few communities of society such as SC/ST/OBC.But I have also seen some peculiar thing which are loopholes in this reservation policy such as low cutoff marks, low percentage relaxation ,age relaxation etc.These things should be eradicated.

    Anyways I should not be more aggressive towards few communities because its not good for me and forum.So lets stop here.

    Regards Saurav

  7. #7
    shadabm is offline Junior Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2012
    Location
    Pune
    Posts
    848

    Re: Job reservation are Violation of right to equality or Not.

    Hello dear,

    The reservation was initiated to uplift the social status of the group of the people who were devoid of their social and
    educational rights . This reservation scheme helped a lot in achieving its motive.

    But a clause was also added in reservation policy that this policy should be revisited so that some modification can be done
    so as to minimise the misuse of this reservation policy. But this clause is not being followed and this is the reason due to which
    reservation is not helping the genuine needy people.
    In current scenario of India, its correct some section of society still needs lot of growth to come in parallel to average Indian growth
    but instead of job reservations, I believe, reservation at education level is enough to bring them equal to other section of society.

    next point is that job reservation impacts the country's growth as well because candidates with very low marks get the job while
    candidates with high marks and high merit are denied to get job. It also creates a lot of frustration among students.

    So overall I believe Reservation upto education level is good to make the Institutions give admission to the required section
    of society to gain proper education but after this Jobs should only be granted based on education merit.

  8. #8
    koti.kwr is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Location
    Hyderabad
    Posts
    2,284

    Re: Job reservation are Violation of right to equality or Not.

    Hi Guest,


    Right to equality is written in ARTICLE 14 to 18 of our Indian Constitution.


    To be frank job reservation are violation to right to equality. In case of reservation you see that there is no equality between all the candidates.


    The candidates of backward classes are given reservation whereas the normal OC candidates are not given any kind of reservation; this is absolutely a violation to right to equality.

    The right to eaulity is said to be perfect when all the students are seen in a right manner and no other preferences are given.


    The right to equality is described as follows: “The state shall not discriminate against any citizen on grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex, place or birth or any of them”.


    Thank You,

    All the Best.

  9. #9
    Unregistered Guest

    Re: Job reservation are Violation of right to equality or Not.

    yes you ar abssolutely correct dude

  10. #10
    Unregistered Guest

    Re: Job reservation are Violation of right to equality or Not.

    you are all wrong.

  11. #11
    Unregistered Guest

    Re: Job reservation are Violation of right to equality or Not.

    i dont know

  12. #12
    Thangkhokai haokip is offline Junior Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2013
    Posts
    1

    Re: Job reservation are Violation of right to equality or Not.

    aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

  13. #13
    Unregistered Guest

    Re: Job reservation are Violation of right to equality or Not.

    plz give more points on '' job reservation ARE violation of right to equality

  14. #14
    Unregistered Guest

    Re: Job reservation are Violation of right to equality or Not.

    Izvfiugvugvggivgvijjkvhvkhjhvkjkvj

+ Reply to Thread

Quick Reply Any Question?

Similar Threads

  1. cet reservations for medical for obc
    By Unregistered in forum Government Jobs Discussions
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 27th April 2013, 10:11 PM